Finished reading?

Mark it as read & it’s ticked off across Cryptopedia, including the Crypto Tax & Regulations learning path.

Chris Shepley
Reviewed byChris Shepley

Founder & CEO of Shepley Capital, Adelaide. Cryptopedia guides are written by the Shepley Capital team & reviewed by Chris.

About Chris
Go deeper

Guides linked in this article.

guides across Cryptopedia, coloured by category.

Fresh from the category

Latest in Crypto Tax & Regulations.

Premium intelligence

Stay ahead of the digital asset economy.

Access deeper market intelligence, research, and premium guidance through the Shepley Capital membership ecosystem. Built for investors who want more than information.

CRYPTO TAX AND REGULATIONS
Crypto Tax and Regulations - Cryptopedia by Shepley Capital

The "Carrying On a Business" Test: How the ATO Classifies Crypto Traders

In short: whether your crypto activity is a business depends on its overall character, weighed across several indicators such as a significant commercial purpose, repetition and regularity, size or scale, and a business-like, organised approach, the indicators the ATO sets out in Taxation Ruling TR 97/11. If you are in business, the ATO says crypto is trading stock: costs are generally deductible, proceeds are ordinary income and the CGT discount does not apply. The key points:

  • No single factor, transaction count or dollar figure decides it.
  • Most individual investors, even active ones, are not carrying on a business.
  • A business brings trading stock rules, wider deductions and different loss rules.
  • Reassess as your activity changes, and keep a note of your reasoning.

Almost every other decision covered across Australian crypto tax, from whether the CGT discount applies to what expenses can be deducted, ultimately depends on one foundational classification: is a given crypto activity being conducted as an investor, or does it constitute carrying on a business. This guide focuses specifically on the underlying test itself, the actual factors the ATO weighs when making that determination, since understanding the test properly is what allows an investor to self-assess their own position honestly rather than defaulting to whichever answer seems more convenient.

From 1 July 2027 the CGT rules change for gains that build up after that date, so see our guide to the 2027 CGT changes too.

 

There Is No Single Deciding Factor

The “carrying on a business” test is a holistic, factual assessment, not a single bright-line rule based on transaction count or dollar value alone. The ATO weighs a combination of factors together: the scale and frequency of the activity, whether it is conducted in a systematic, organised, business-like manner with proper records, whether there is a genuine, ongoing intention and reasonable prospect of profit, the amount of capital committed, and whether the activity resembles what would ordinarily be recognised as a business in a similar field.

This mirrors the same underlying logic applied to distinguishing a frequent trader from a long-term holder, but the business test extends beyond just trading frequency to the overall character of the activity. Someone making occasional, considered investment decisions, even reasonably often, looks different to someone running crypto activity with the scale, systems and genuine profit focus of a commercial operation. Reviewing the general ATO rules for crypto in Australia alongside these specific factors, rather than relying on a rule of thumb, is the honest way to self-assess.

 

The Indicators in Practice

TR 97/11 was written for primary production, but its indicators are the ones generally used to decide whether any activity is a business. Applied to crypto, they look like this:

  • Significant commercial purpose. Is the activity run to make money from trading itself, rather than to grow a long-term portfolio?
  • Intention and prospect of profit. Is there a genuine plan to profit from the activity, with a realistic expectation of doing so?
  • Repetition and regularity. Frequent, systematic trading, for example day trading or running a validator, points towards a business; occasional purchases and sales do not.
  • Organisation and records. A written trading plan, separate accounts, crypto tax software and business-like records point towards a business.
  • Size or scale. The capital committed and the volume of trades, compared with how a commercial operation would look.
  • Similarity to the industry. Whether the activity is carried on like a crypto trading, mining or market-making business.

The ATO weighs these together. Someone who buys Bitcoin monthly through dollar-cost averaging and sells a few times a year is an investor, however large the portfolio. Someone trading perpetuals daily from a dedicated setup with a documented strategy may well be in business.

Why the Classification Changes So Much

Under the current rules, an individual investor can get the 50% CGT discount on assets held at least 12 months, which is not available on trading stock or business income; from 1 July 2027 the 2027 CGT changes replace the discount for later growth anyway. A business, on the other hand, treats crypto as trading stock under the ATO’s guidance on crypto assets used in business: the cost of acquiring crypto is generally deductible, proceeds are ordinary income, and you may need to value trading stock on hand at year end. Business expenses, similar in principle to mining deductions, can also be claimed. Business losses can offset other income, but for individuals the non-commercial loss rules may defer them unless certain tests are met, whereas a capital loss can only offset capital gains.

This trade-off is exactly why the classification matters so much, and why it should be assessed honestly based on the actual facts rather than chosen for whichever treatment looks more favourable in a given year. Someone whose crypto activity has scaled considerably, perhaps trading with genuine frequency, using leverage, or committing capital in a way that resembles a professional operation more than a personal investment habit, needs to seriously consider whether business classification now more accurately reflects the reality of what they are doing, using a consistent cost base method either way to keep the underlying records defensible.

 

Two Short Examples

Priya works full time, buys Ether and Bitcoin each month, and sells part of her holdings two or three times a year to rebalance. She is an investor: her disposals are CGT events and she can use the discount on assets held at least 12 months. Ben has left his job to trade crypto full time, executes dozens of trades a day under a written strategy, uses leverage and keeps business accounts. He is likely carrying on a business, so his crypto is trading stock, his net trading profit is ordinary income, and his data, software and equipment costs are generally deductible. Many people sit between these two, which is where a specialist accountant earns their fee.

Structuring, Reassessing and Getting It Wrong

For crypto activity that has genuinely reached business scale, structuring the activity through a company or trust, and understanding how that interacts with multiple entities or a family trust structure, becomes a genuinely relevant consideration, distinct from the classification question itself but closely connected to it. This is not a decision to make once and never revisit. As activity scales up or down over time, the classification that was accurate three years ago may no longer reflect current reality, and periodically reassessing against the actual factors, rather than assuming the original classification still holds, is good practice.

Misclassifying genuinely business-scale activity as personal investing, whether to access the CGT discount inappropriately or simply through inattention, is a real compliance risk given the ATO’s data matching program and broader visibility into crypto activity. Where there is genuine uncertainty, this is exactly the kind of foundational question worth resolving with a specialist accountant before lodging a return, rather than defaulting to an assumption either way, and any activity that does not fit a clean pattern is worth reviewing against the broader set of crypto tax edge cases. All income and disposals still need to be reported as explained in our guide to declaring crypto on your tax return, correctly reflecting whichever classification the facts actually support.

 

Key Takeaways

The “carrying on a business” test is a holistic assessment of multiple factors together, not a single rule based on transaction count or dollar value alone. The classification determines access to the CGT discount, what expenses can be deducted, and how losses are treated, making it foundational to almost every other crypto tax question. Activity that has genuinely scaled up over time should be periodically reassessed against the actual factors, not judged once and left unreviewed. Misclassification is a real, visible compliance risk given the ATO’s data matching capability, and genuine uncertainty is worth resolving with professional advice.

This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or tax advice. Australian crypto tax law is complex and subject to change; consult a registered tax agent or accountant regarding your specific circumstances before making any decisions.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the carrying on a business test for crypto?

It decides whether your crypto activity is investing or a business. The ATO weighs indicators together, such as a significant commercial purpose, intention and prospect of profit, repetition and regularity, organisation and size or scale, as set out in TR 97/11. If you are in business, crypto is trading stock: costs are generally deductible, proceeds are ordinary income and the CGT discount does not apply.

Which factors does the ATO weigh in the business test?

The "carrying on a business" test is a holistic, factual assessment, not a single bright-line rule based on transaction count or dollar value alone. The ATO weighs a combination of factors together: the scale and frequency of the activity, whether it is conducted in a systematic, organised, business-like manner with proper records, whether there is a genuine, ongoing intention and reasonable prospect of profit, the amount of capital committed, and whether the activity resembles what would ordinarily be recognised as a business in a similar field.

Why the Classification Changes So Much?

An investor's disposals are CGT events, and under the current rules individuals can get the 50% discount on assets held at least 12 months. A business treats crypto as trading stock, so costs are generally deductible and proceeds are ordinary income with no discount. Business losses can offset other income, subject to the non-commercial loss rules, while capital losses only offset capital gains.

How should genuine crypto business activity be structured?

For crypto activity that has genuinely reached business scale, structuring the activity through a company or trust, and understanding how that interacts with multiple entities or a family trust structure, becomes a genuinely relevant consideration, distinct from the classification question itself but closely connected to it. This is not a decision to make once and never revisit. As activity scales up or down over time, the classification that was accurate three years ago may no longer reflect current reality, and periodically reassessing against the actual factors, rather than assuming the original classification still holds, is good practice.

What are the key points on the carrying on a business test?

The "carrying on a business" test is a holistic assessment of multiple factors together, not a single rule based on transaction count or dollar value alone. The classification determines access to the CGT discount, what expenses can be deducted, and how losses are treated, making it foundational to almost every other crypto tax question. Activity that has genuinely scaled up over time should be periodically reassessed against the actual factors, not judged once and left unreviewed.

What are the ATO reporting requirements for The “Carrying On a Business” Test?

Classification determines the reporting basis, so settle it before the return is prepared. An investor reports disposals as CGT events and may get the discount on assets held at least 12 months under the current rules. A business reports net trading profit as ordinary income, applies the trading stock rules, including stock on hand at year end, and claims business expenses.

How does The "Carrying On a Business" Test affect Australian crypto investors?

The practical consequence is significant. Losing investor status removes the 50 per cent CGT discount, so a gain previously taxed on half its value becomes fully assessable, and the ATO can apply that view to earlier years. The exposure runs both ways, since someone genuinely carrying on a business who reports as an investor may be denied deductions they were entitled to claim. Where the pattern is genuinely borderline, confirming the position with a registered tax agent before lodging is cheaper than correcting it afterwards.

What records should I keep for The “Carrying On a Business” Test in Australia?

Keep the usual crypto records for every transaction: dates, AUD values, wallet addresses, exchange records and what each transaction was for. If you may be in business, also keep a trading plan, business bank records, expense invoices and year-end valuations of crypto on hand. A short note of why you concluded you are, or are not, in business is useful if the ATO asks.

WRITTEN & REVIEWED BY Chris Shepley

UPDATED: JULY 2026

Choose your next topic from our Cryptopedia​

Footer | Shepley Capital

Grow your crypto portfolio with the latest insights, straight to your inbox!

Join 10,150+ CEOs, Business Owners, Parents, Students, & more receiving actionable crypto insights to grow their portfolios.