In short: the sunk cost fallacy is the urge to keep putting money, time or effort into something because of what you have already spent, even when the outlook is poor. In crypto it shows up as holding a falling coin until it gets back to even, averaging down without a reason, or paying more to a platform or scammer to recover earlier losses. The key points:
- Money already lost is gone whatever you do next, so decisions should look forward.
- A simple test is whether you would buy the asset today at its current price.
- Scammers deliberately use this bias by demanding fees before withdrawals.
- In Australia, a realised capital loss can offset capital gains, but wash sales are not allowed.
The bias was shown in a classic 1985 study by Arkes and Blumer. Moneysmart’s overview of crypto assets covers the risks, Scamwatch explains current scams, and the ATO’s guidance on CGT on crypto covers how losses are treated.
Most people who invest in crypto for long enough end up holding something that has fallen far below what they paid. The instinct is to hold on, add more to lower the average price or wait until it gets back to even, because selling would make the loss real. That instinct has a name: the sunk cost fallacy. It is the tendency to keep investing time, money or effort in something because of what has already been spent, even when the evidence says the future looks poor. It is one of the most expensive mistakes in investing, and crypto, with its volatility, its emotional communities and its constant temptation to average down, is a place where it thrives. This guide explains what sunk costs are, why we fall for them, how the pattern shows up in crypto, how to think about decisions in a better way and how tax rules can change the picture for Australians.
What a Sunk Cost Is
A sunk cost is money, time or effort that has already been spent and cannot be recovered. The important idea from economics is that a rational decision looks only at the future: what will happen from here, given the choices available now. What you paid in the past is the same whichever choice you make, so it should not influence the choice. If you paid A$10,000 for a token that is now worth A$2,000, the A$8,000 loss has already happened. The question that matters is not how to get the A$8,000 back, but what is the best use of the A$2,000 today.
Why We Fall for It
We hate admitting mistakes: selling at a loss feels like conceding that the original decision was wrong, which hurts our sense of competence.
Losses hurt more than gains feel good: people weigh losses more heavily than equivalent gains, a tendency known as loss aversion in crypto.
A loss on paper feels different from a realised one: as long as you hold, the loss is not final, so there is always hope.
We want consistency: having told ourselves and others that a project is great, changing our minds feels awkward.
We become attached: the time spent researching and following a project makes it feel like part of us.
Community pressure: being part of a group of believers makes leaving feel like betrayal. Crowd behaviour and herd mentality in crypto make this worse.
A Simple Example With Made-Up Numbers
Suppose you bought a token at $1, and it has fallen to $0.20. You have 10,000 tokens, so your holding cost $10,000 and is now worth $2,000. Someone offers you a clean choice: sell today and put the $2,000 into another asset you research and believe in, or keep holding in the hope that it returns to $1. If you ignore the past, the decision is simply which use of $2,000 has the better prospects. But the sunk cost fallacy reframes it as giving up $8,000, which feels unbearable, so you hold. If the token has weak prospects, holding does not undo the loss, and it also costs you the chance to use the money elsewhere. The numbers are invented, but the trap is real.
How It Shows Up in Crypto
Bag-holding: hanging on to a coin long after the reasons for buying it have disappeared, telling yourself it is a long-term hold.
Averaging down without a thesis: buying more as the price falls to reduce your average cost, not because you have new evidence, but to justify the original purchase. Averaging into a strong asset on a plan is different from throwing good money after bad.
Waiting to break even: refusing to sell until the price returns to what you paid, as though the market owed you that price.
Staying with a failing platform: leaving money on an exchange or in a protocol showing warning signs because moving it feels like admitting a mistake. The consequences of crypto exchange bankruptcy and the FTX collapse show this.
Doubling down on leveraged losers: adding collateral or increasing size to a losing leveraged position instead of accepting the loss, which can end in liquidation. Understanding leverage trading and how liquidation works shows why.
Chasing recovery: making riskier bets to win back losses quickly, a pattern closely tied to trading addiction in crypto and self-sabotage in crypto trading.
Falling for recovery scams: people who have lost money to a fraud are often targeted again by scammers who promise to recover it for a fee. The same trap appears in scam recovery, where victims keep paying to get money back.
Scams Exploit the Sunk Cost Fallacy
Fraudsters understand this bias well. Fake investment platforms show growing balances so that victims deposit more, then invent fees and taxes that must be paid before money can be withdrawn. Each payment makes the victim feel that stopping would waste what they have already paid, so they pay again. The same pattern appears in romance and pig-butchering scams, where victims are led to keep investing because they have invested so much already. If you notice that you are being asked to pay more in order to get your money back, stop and learn how to avoid crypto scams, how Ponzi schemes work in crypto and how to report a crypto scam.
How to Think About It Instead
The best antidote is to reframe every holding as if you were deciding today. Ask yourself: if I had the cash instead of this token, would I buy it at today’s price? If the answer is no, then holding it is effectively the same as buying it again. This “would I buy it now” test strips away the history and forces you to judge the asset on its current merits. A second question is what else you could do with the money. Holding a weak position has an opportunity cost, since the capital could be working in something you believe in more.
Practical Rules to Reduce the Bias
Decide exits in advance: write down, before you buy, what would make you sell, including a price or a reason. Use a written trading plan and consider stop losses.
Limit position size: the smaller the position, the easier it is to walk away. Good position sizing and the one percent risk rule limit how much any one position can hurt.
Use a pre-trade checklist: including a note of your thesis, which you can check later. A pre-trade checklist makes this practical.
Review positions regularly: with a schedule and a record, using a crypto investment journal and trade reviews.
Separate thesis from price: a fall in price is not the same as a broken thesis, and a rise is not proof that it is intact. Ask whether the reasons you bought still hold.
Seek outside views: someone without your history can often judge more clearly.
Detach emotionally: practise viewing positions as numbers on a screen. It helps to learn how to detach emotionally from crypto positions.
Averaging Down: When Is It Sensible?
Buying more of something after a fall is not always the fallacy. If you planned to accumulate over time, have a clear thesis that has not changed and have set a limit on how much of your portfolio the asset can be, then adding at lower prices can be reasonable. The fallacy occurs when the only reason for buying more is to make your past decision look better. A useful test is whether you would be comfortable making the same purchase if you had never owned the asset before. Regular purchases on a schedule, or dollar-cost averaging, are a structured approach, while emotional doubling down is not. Be careful, too, about buy-the-dip strategies applied to assets that may not recover.
Coping With Losses
Letting go of a loss is emotionally hard, and it helps to accept that everyone who invests takes losses. Professionals expect to be wrong often and manage their risk so that losses are survivable. Learning to handle losses as a trader, cope with a fifty percent drawdown in your portfolio and deal with a crypto market crash all help. Avoid selling in a panic, too, since the opposite mistake exists: panic selling can crystallise losses at the worst moment. The goal is a clear-headed decision, not automatic holding or automatic selling.
The Tax Angle for Australians
For Australian investors, realising a loss can have a tax benefit. A capital loss can generally be used to offset capital gains, and unused losses can be carried forward, which means selling a loser can reduce tax on gains elsewhere. That does not make it right to sell any asset for tax reasons alone, but it is a useful reminder that holding a loser purely to avoid making the loss real can have a cost. The tax side covers crypto capital losses, tax loss harvesting, how to report crypto losses and delisted token losses. The ATO has warned that wash sales, selling and quickly buying back the same asset just to create a loss, can be caught by anti-avoidance rules, so get professional advice, and keep good crypto tax records.
A Short Exercise for Your Own Portfolio
Open a list of everything you currently hold and, for each position, write two lines: why you would buy it today at the current price, and what would make you sell it. Positions where you struggle to write the first line are candidates for review, and positions where you cannot write the second are ones where you have no plan. It also helps to note how each position is sized relative to your whole portfolio, using guides such as crypto portfolio rebalancing and understanding risk management, and how it fits your time horizon. Doing this once a quarter takes less than an hour and often reveals holdings you are keeping only because of history.
Common Misconceptions
“A loss is not a loss until I sell”: the value has already gone; selling only records it.
“It has to come back”: markets owe no one a return to any particular price, and many assets never recover.
“Selling means I was wrong”: changing your mind when the facts change is good decision-making.
“Never sell at a loss”: sometimes holding is right, but the reason should be about the future, not the past.
“Averaging down always lowers risk”: it increases your exposure to something that is falling.
Sunk Costs Beyond Money
The fallacy applies to time and effort too. People stay in a failed project, a course that is not working or a trading strategy that is losing because of the hours already devoted. Ask what you would do if you were starting today with what you know now, and be honest about whether continuing is the best use of your remaining time and money. Building the ability to make those judgements is part of developing the skills of a successful trader or investor and using a crypto investment decision-making framework.
Key Takeaways
The sunk cost fallacy is the tendency to keep committing to something because of what has already been spent. In crypto, it shows up as bag-holding, averaging down without a reason, waiting to break even, staying with failing platforms, chasing losses and falling for scams that demand more money. The past spend is gone whatever you choose, so the only sensible question is what gives you the best prospects from here.
Use the “would I buy it today” test, decide exits in advance, keep positions small enough that walking away is possible, review holdings against your original thesis and seek outside views. For Australian investors, remember that realised losses can be useful for tax, but treat that as a reason to make clear decisions, not as a trick. Keep good records and get advice for anything complicated.