Finished reading?

Mark it as read & it’s ticked off across Cryptopedia, including the Crypto Tax & Regulations learning path.

Chris Shepley
Reviewed byChris Shepley

Founder & CEO of Shepley Capital, Adelaide. Cryptopedia guides are written by the Shepley Capital team & reviewed by Chris.

About Chris
Go deeper

Guides linked in this article.

guides across Cryptopedia, coloured by category.

Fresh from the category

Latest in Crypto Tax & Regulations.

Premium intelligence

Stay ahead of the digital asset economy.

Access deeper market intelligence, research, and premium guidance through the Shepley Capital membership ecosystem. Built for investors who want more than information.

INVESTMENT STRATEGIES
Investment Strategies - Cryptopedia by Shepley Capital

How Grayscale Converted GBTC to a Bitcoin ETF

In short: the Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) was a US trust holding Bitcoin whose shares traded over the counter, often at a large discount to the value of the Bitcoin it held, because shares could not be redeemed. On 10 January 2024 the US Securities and Exchange Commission approved GBTC and ten other spot Bitcoin products for exchange listing, in its approval order. Once shares could be created and redeemed, the discount closed. The key points:

  • The approval followed a 2023 court ruling that the SEC had not justified rejecting Grayscale’s application.
  • GBTC became an exchange-traded product, listed as commodity-based trust shares, not a fund registered under the Investment Company Act.
  • Its fee fell from 2% to 1.5% at listing, still well above new competitors, and large outflows followed.
  • For Australians, it is a lesson in how product structure and fees affect returns.

Before conversion, GBTC was the largest Bitcoin investment vehicle for most of its life, and the change was a milestone in institutional adoption. The launch of US spot Bitcoin ETFs in January 2024 brought large new inflows, discussed in our guide to the institutional price effect, although many factors drive prices.

The Grayscale Bitcoin Trust Structure and the Discount Problem

Before conversion, GBTC was a closed structure: shares were issued to accredited investors in private placements and could later be sold on the over-the-counter market, but holders could not redeem them for Bitcoin. Exchange-traded products, by contrast, allow authorised participants to create and redeem shares, which keeps the market price close to the value of the underlying assets, as our crypto ETF guide explains. Without redemptions, GBTC’s price depended only on supply and demand for its shares. When demand fell from early 2021, the shares moved to a growing discount to net asset value (NAV), reaching close to 50% around the end of 2022.

The discount is simply the gap between the value of the Bitcoin behind each share and the share price, divided by that value. If the Bitcoin behind a share is worth US$100 and the share trades at US$70, the discount is 30%, regardless of how much Bitcoin each share represents. A deep discount was both an opportunity and a risk. Buyers effectively paid less than the Bitcoin was worth, and some traded on the expectation that it would close. But there was no guarantee of conversion, the discount could widen further, and the 2% annual fee kept reducing the Bitcoin held per share. Applying the same research discipline as for any investment meant weighing the chance and timing of conversion against those costs.

The Court Ruling and the 2024 Approval

Grayscale challenged the SEC’s rejection of its conversion application, arguing that it was arbitrary to approve Bitcoin futures ETFs while rejecting spot products. In August 2023, the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit agreed that the SEC had not adequately explained its reasoning, vacated the rejection and sent the application back for review, as the SEC Chair noted in his statement on the approval. On 10 January 2024 the SEC approved spot Bitcoin exchange-traded products from several sponsors, including Grayscale, and trading began the next day. Our guides to crypto regulation in Australia and the legal risks of crypto cover the local framework.

Once GBTC listed, creations and redemptions brought the share price close to NAV, and holders who had bought at a discount captured that gap on top of any change in Bitcoin’s price. But GBTC’s fee, cut to 1.5%, remained much higher than the fees of competing products launched the same day, many of them around 0.2% to 0.25%, and billions of US dollars flowed out of GBTC in the following weeks as investors switched to cheaper alternatives. Combined inflows into the new products were larger than GBTC’s outflows over the following months, as our guides to market cycles and the institutional price effect discuss.

Tax for Australian Holders

Australian residents who bought GBTC through an international broker hold a foreign-listed security. Selling it is a CGT event under Australian law, and individuals who held for at least 12 months can generally halve the gain under the ATO’s CGT discount rules. Each purchase and sale must be converted to Australian dollars at the exchange rate on the day, so currency movements affect the gain as well as the share price. The conversion itself was not a sale by shareholders, but switching from GBTC to a cheaper fund means selling one and buying another, which is a CGT event. Our guides to capital gains tax, record keeping and overseas assets cover the detail.

Australian Implications of the GBTC ETF Conversion

The clearest lesson for Australian investors is that structure and fees shape outcomes. GBTC buyers who bought at a deep discount did well when it closed, but the 2% fee ate into their holdings for years, and buyers near the 2021 peak suffered both Bitcoin’s fall and a widening discount. Products that allow creations and redemptions, with competitive fees, avoid the persistent discount problem.

Australia’s own spot crypto ETFs are open structures with authorised participants. The Global X 21Shares Bitcoin ETF (EBTC) has traded since May 2022 on what is now TMX Australia Exchange, formerly Cboe Australia, and the VanEck Bitcoin ETF (VBTC) became the first spot Bitcoin ETF on the ASX in June 2024. Our guides to crypto ETFs for Australians, Bitcoin spot ETFs and the spot versus futures distinction cover the local products.

The episode also showed how large institutional flows can affect prices for some time after a regulatory milestone. Regulatory timing is hard to predict, and markets often move before or after the event in ways that are hard to anticipate, so building a position around a single expected milestone is risky. Our guides to portfolio allocation, how much to put in crypto and Bitcoin cycle strategy offer a steadier framework, along with our long-term portfolio guide.

Lessons in Patience and Structure

Holding GBTC through 2022 meant enduring Bitcoin’s fall of more than 70% from its peak plus a discount of up to about 50%. Investors who held on until 2024 were rewarded, but only those who could afford to wait and had no need to sell at the worst time. That is the case for an emergency buffer, sensible risk management and the patience and discipline covered in our guides to bear market investing and dealing with a crash. Valuation tools such as the MVRV ratio and on-chain data, and an awareness of fear and greed, can help investors keep perspective.

The wider point is that regulation of crypto products moves at the pace of courts, regulators and politics, not technology. The SEC rejected spot Bitcoin ETFs for years before a court ruling changed the outcome. Australia has its own path, with ASX-listed spot ETFs since 2024, AUSTRAC registration for exchanges, as covered in our guide to AUSTRAC, and platform licensing from 8 April 2027. Further product types, such as funds that stake their holdings, may follow in some markets, but their timing is uncertain. Our guide to the halving cycle covers another factor investors often watch.

Why Fees Mattered So Much

An annual fee is taken from the fund’s assets, so a higher fee steadily reduces the amount of Bitcoin behind each share. Over five years, a 2% fee removes close to a tenth of the holdings, while a 0.25% fee removes just over 1%. That difference compounds regardless of what Bitcoin’s price does. When cheaper products became available in January 2024, many GBTC holders weighed the fee saving against the tax cost of selling, and those without large gains or holding in tax-advantaged accounts often switched. Australians comparing local products face the same trade-off, and should look at the total annual cost as well as brokerage.

Key Terms

  • Net asset value (NAV): the value of the assets a fund holds, per share or unit.
  • Premium or discount: how far the market price sits above or below NAV.
  • Authorised participant: a large dealer that can create or redeem shares with the fund, which keeps the price close to NAV.
  • Sponsor or management fee: the annual charge taken from the fund’s assets, covered in our guide to trading fees.
  • Futures ETF: a fund holding futures contracts rather than the coin, explained in our guide to Bitcoin futures ETFs.

The Ethereum Sequel

Grayscale’s Ethereum Trust (ETHE) followed a similar path. It too had traded at a discount, and it converted when US spot Ether products began trading in July 2024. As with GBTC, the higher fee of the converted trust led to outflows as investors compared it with cheaper new products. Our guide to the Ethereum ETF covers the products available to Australians.

How to Check a Product’s Structure

  • Can shares or units be created and redeemed by authorised participants? If not, the price can drift far from the value of the assets.
  • What is the total annual fee, and how does it compare with similar products?
  • Does the market price usually trade close to NAV? Issuers publish both.
  • Who holds the assets, and is the custodian named in the disclosure documents?
  • For overseas products, what are the currency, tax and access implications for an Australian?

Our guides to evaluating a crypto ETF, accessing crypto ETFs in Australia and ETFs versus direct ownership go further. The same discount issue can affect other closed structures, such as some listed investment companies on the ASX, so the question applies beyond crypto.

A Worked Example

Suppose an investor bought GBTC in late 2022 when each share represented roughly US$15 of Bitcoin but traded near US$8, a discount of close to 50%. By the time GBTC listed in January 2024, Bitcoin had risen strongly and the discount had all but disappeared, so the investor gained from both. Another investor who bought in early 2021 near NAV suffered Bitcoin’s fall and the opening of the discount before recovering. The figures are rounded and illustrative only, and past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.

Timeline

  • 2013 onwards: GBTC launched as a private trust; shares later traded over the counter.
  • 2021: the premium turned into a discount as demand fell.
  • Late 2022: the discount approached 50% during the bear market.
  • August 2023: the DC Circuit vacated the SEC’s rejection of Grayscale’s application.
  • 10 January 2024: the SEC approved spot Bitcoin products, including GBTC; trading began the next day.
  • 2024: large outflows from GBTC as investors moved to lower-fee products.

Frequently Asked Questions

How did Grayscale convert GBTC into a Bitcoin ETF?

After a US court ruled in August 2023 that the SEC had not justified rejecting Grayscale's application, the SEC approved GBTC and ten other spot Bitcoin products for exchange listing on 10 January 2024. GBTC listed on NYSE Arca as commodity-based trust shares, with creations and redemptions, and its fee fell from 2% to 1.5%.

Why did the Grayscale trust trade at a discount?

Before conversion, GBTC shares could not be redeemed for Bitcoin, so their price depended only on supply and demand. When demand fell from 2021, the shares traded below the value of the Bitcoin behind them, with the discount approaching 50% around the end of 2022. Once redemptions were allowed in 2024, the discount closed.

What was Grayscale's legal argument against the SEC?

Grayscale argued it was arbitrary for the SEC to approve Bitcoin futures ETFs while rejecting spot Bitcoin products. In August 2023 the DC Circuit agreed the SEC had not adequately explained the difference, vacated the rejection and sent the application back. The SEC then approved spot Bitcoin products in January 2024.

Why does the GBTC conversion matter to Australian investors?

It shows how product structure and fees affect returns. Australians who held GBTC through an overseas broker own a foreign security: selling is a CGT event, each trade is converted to Australian dollars, and the discount applies after at least 12 months for individuals. Australian spot ETFs allow creations and redemptions, which avoids persistent discounts.

What do Australian investors need to know about Australian Implications of the GBTC ETF Conversion?

Australia's spot crypto ETFs are open structures with authorised participants. Global X's EBTC has traded since May 2022 on what is now TMX Australia Exchange, and VanEck's VBTC became the first spot Bitcoin ETF on the ASX in June 2024. Compare fees and check that a product's price tracks its net asset value.

What does the GBTC discount period teach about patience?

Holding GBTC through 2022 meant enduring Bitcoin's fall of over 70% plus a discount of up to about 50%. Investors who held until 2024 were rewarded, but only those who could afford to wait. Keep an emergency buffer, size positions sensibly, and avoid building a plan around a single expected regulatory event.

What are the risks illustrated by the GBTC episode?

GBTC showed that the structure holding an asset can matter as much as the asset itself. Because the closed-end trust had no redemption mechanism, its units traded up to roughly 50 per cent below the value of the Bitcoin behind them, and holders had no way to close the gap. Investors also paid a 2 per cent annual fee throughout. The general lesson is that any wrapper with no redemption path can disconnect from its underlying value for years.

What should Australians take from the GBTC conversion?

The practical takeaway is to check how a product redeems before buying it, since that mechanism is what keeps price aligned with value. Australians accessing US-listed products should also weigh currency exposure and cross-border tax considerations against the locally listed alternatives. The episode is a case study in structural risk rather than a reason to expect similar discounts to reappear.

Choose your next topic from our Cryptopedia​

Footer | Shepley Capital

Grow your crypto portfolio with the latest insights, straight to your inbox!

Join 10,150+ CEOs, Business Owners, Parents, Students, & more receiving actionable crypto insights to grow their portfolios.